The new bill* re-drafted by Congressman Payne retains much of the legislative findings and provisions of H.R. 5680 (the “Ethiopia Freedom, Democracy and Human Rights Advancement Act of 2006), and ‘regime accountability’ is the centerpiece of the legislation.
The Coalition of HR 5680 is mindful of the high degree of commitment being made by Congressman Payne, who is also chairman of the subcommittee on Africa, Global Human Rights and International Operations.
Specifically, the new bill:
Emphasizes current regime accountability by affirmatively stating that it is the policy of
the United States to seek the immediate and unconditional release of all political prisoners
and prisoners of conscience. This emphasis is manifest in light of the evidence the new bill
incorporates from the findings of the Inquiry Commission and the U.S. Department of
State’s 2006 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices, Ethiopia. Effectively, the new
bill recognizes the release of political prisoners and prisoners of conscience as a top priority, and
now appears second in line in the legislative statement of U.S. policy, ahead of the
collaboration on the global war on terror.
Moreover, using the findings of the Inquiry
Commission, the new bill sends a clear message to the ruling regime that excessive use of
force against peaceful citizens, lack of respect for human rights, rampant conditions of
beatings and physical and mental abuse, mistreatment of detainees and opposition
supporters, poor prison conditions and arbitrary arrests and detentions are condemned by
the U.S. Congress.
Underscores retrospective regime accountability by demanding the prosecution and
punishment of the killers of the unarmed protesters in the period following the May, 2005
elections. It is clear the new bill seeks
accountability not only for the criminal and lawless acts of the security forces, but also
others who may have had material participation and involvement in the commission of these
gross abuses of human rights. The bill intends that all persons who have engaged in gross
human rights abuses will be brought to justice.
Aims to ensure prospective regime accountability by preventing the future recurrence
of extrajudicial killings and massacres such as those that took place after the 2005
elections. The new bill adds 10 extraordinary paragraphs meticulously documenting the
massive scope of human rights violations in Ethiopia as set forth in the findings of the
Inquiry Commission and the U.S. Department of State’s 2006 Country Reports on Human
Rights Practices, Ethiopia. The findings of gross abuses of human rights in the new bill are so detailed it includes individual victims such as Etenesh Yemam, and her daughter Alemzuria.
Etenesh’s husband was elected to the Addis Ababa City Council, and she was shot in cold
blood as she pleaded with so-called security officers to release him. Justice for the innocent
detainees who were massacred in Kality prison is also specifically mentioned. The inclusion
of the extensive new findings sends a clear message to the ruling regime in Ethiopia that
massacres, extrajudicial killings, arbitrary detentions and other gross violations of human
rights will not be tolerated by the United States.
Aims to use regime accountability as a means of immediately ending gross abuses of
human rights and the violence perpetrated by the regime against opposition elements,
dissenters and others. In this regard, the incorporation of the findings of the Inquiry
commission and the 2006 U.S. State Department Human Rights report clearly indicates the
sense of Congress that future U.S. policy and relations with Ethiopia will depend a great
deal on the ruling regime’s transparency and accountability on the issue of human rights,
and its restraint in the use of indiscriminate violence against citizens.
Sends a clear message to the ruling regime that it must be transparent and accountable
on its human rights record to its citizens and the international community, and take
immediate remedial action to comply with human rights conventions. Consistent with H.R.
5680, the new bill offers a package of financial and technical support to the regime to
achieve the objective of human rights accountability by strengthen human rights
monitoring, creating a victims support network for political prisoners, increasing the
independence and monitoring of the judiciary, and strengthening the private media, among
other things.
Doubles the level of financial support to the ruling regime for human rights accountability
by providing $20 million for each of the fiscal years 2008 and 2009. (H.R. 5680 provided
$10 million for fiscal years 2007 and 2008.)
LIST OF SPECIFIC TEXTUAL CHANGES IN THE NEW BILL
Sec. 1: Short Title: The new bill may be cited as the “Ethiopia Democracy and Accountability Act
of 2007.”
Sec. 3: Findings: Lists facts on 1) human rights abuses as reported in the U.S. Department of
State’s 2006 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices, including lack of free elections, unlawful
killings, beatings, abuse, mistreatment of detainees and opposition supporters, poor prison
conditions, arbitrary arrests and detentions, 2) the findings of the 11-member Commission of
Inquiry charged to investigate whether government security forces used excessive force, caused
damaged to life and property and showed lack of respect for human rights. The Commission’s
findings are reported in great detail in 9 paragraphs.
Sec. 6 (3) (D): Specifically requires that the security personnel involved in the unlawful killings of
demonstrators, Etenesh Yemam and Kaliti prisoners are punished.
Sec. 7: Provides support for economic development assistance to Ethiopia. The Agency for
International Development is expected to provide assistance for sustainable development of the
Nile and Awash River resources, including technical assistance for irrigation system development
and hydroelectric power to prevent future famines. Additionally, support is provided for health care
assistance to hospitals and health care centers in rural areas. Prior provisions for assistance in the
areas of taxation, debt management, bank supervision, etc, and financing for commercial ventures
are omitted in the new bill.
Sec. 9: Authorization of Appropriations: The bill provides $20 million for each of the fiscal years
2008 and 2009.
WE SHOULD THANK CHAIRMAN PAYNE
We should thank Chairman Payne not only for what he has done for Ethiopia in this bill and H.R.
5680, but also for his tireless efforts on behalf of the Africa continent.
All Ethiopian Americans and Ethiopian human rights advocates should recognize that Chairman
Payne, by introducing the new bill replacing H.R. 5680, demonstrates his unflagging support and
high level of commitment to the cause of human rights in Ethiopia.
It is equally important for us to appreciate that Chairman Payne has been involved in the cause of
human rights in Africa for a very long time, in addition to all of his tireless efforts to improve the
economic, political and health problems facing the continent.
Among Chairman Payne’s recent efforts on behalf of human rights in the current 110th Congress
include the Torture Victims Relief Reauthorization Act of 2007. He has previously sponsored and
authored numerous bill and resolutions promoting democracy, good governance, human rights,
peaceful conflict resolution and sustainable peace throughout the African continent, including the
Sudan Peace Act and the Zimbabwe Democracy and Economic Recovery Act.
Express your thanks and appreciation to Chairman Payne!
Washington Office
2209 Rayburn House Office Building
Washington, DC 20515
Phone (202) 225-3436
Fax (202) 225-4160
http://www.house.gov/payne/
NEXT STEPS ON THE NEW BILL
There are a number of issues and questions that supporters and advocates of human rights in
Ethiopia will need to address as the new bill begins its journey to the House floor.
A number of issues have been raised by various human rights advocates and groups in the past, and
as part of the “next steps” on the new bill, these issues and questions must be addressed.
Among the critical issues raised to improve the effectiveness of grassroots legislative advocacy for
human rights in Ethiopia include:
the need for increased sophistication in the use legislative
advocacy strategies and tactics,
learning from past mistakes and avoiding the pitfalls of
improvised and haphazard grassroots advocacy,
the need to harness available material, technical
and human resources to produce specific results that maximize passage of a human rights bill, and
the need to develop effective mechanisms to work with congressional members and staff.
We hope such discussions will take place in the near future, and concerted action will be taken to
bring this new bill to the House floor as quickly as possible.
